Showing posts with label Chinese History. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Chinese History. Show all posts

Sunday, February 9, 2014

Graphic Novel Review: Boxers and Saints by Gene Luen Yang

Boxers (Boxers & Saints #1) by Gene Luen Yang


Completion Date: February 5, 2014
Length: 325 Pages

Synopsis from Goodreads:
China, 1898. Bands of foreign missionaries and soldiers roam the countryside, bullying and robbing Chinese peasants.
Little Bao has had enough. Harnessing the powers of ancient Chinese gods, he recruits an army of Boxers--commoners trained in kung fu--who fight to free China from "foreign devils."
Against all odds, this grass-roots rebellion is violently successful. But nothing is simple. Little Bao is fighting for the glory of China, but at what cost? So many are dying, including thousands of "secondary devils"--Chinese citizens who have converted to Christianity.
Yep. Another reread. Another situation where I read book 1 and then never read book 2. And, another book I never reviewed when I read it in June of last year. Frankly, as much as I love graphic novels... I hate reviewing them... Standalones are okay, but I find series impossible because I hate spoiling stuff. Apparently 2013 was just not the year of the graphic novel for me. I did really bad with keeping up on things. This year is about fixing that! Gene Luen Yung has quickly become one of my favourite graphic novel authors. I originally read him in 2009 and have made a point to pay attention to his releases ever since. When I first heard of this duology I knew I was going to have to grab a copy.

I really enjoy a book that makes you want to read more books. That is what was the result of Boxers. I don't know very much about this period in history. Yung's book was a nice introduction, but I really want to explore the topic more in the future. I appreciate that Yung has done this because other people I know also have mentioned wanting to know more. This comic follows Little Bao. Circumstances come together to make Bao grow up very quickly and lead a rebellion against the 'devils' of China. They have moved in and taken over. There has been much death since. There has also been loss of ways with the influx of 'white' believes pushing out the older Chinese customs. It is time for the Chinese to take action and they do in a very spiritual way. (I want to say it is like Magic Realism... I know it isn't really, but from our modern standpoint it is close to it.)

Little Bao is an interesting character. You get to see him grow throughout the book. He doesn't always make the right decisions, but he does what he thinks is in the best interest of China. It made for a very interesting story that I enjoyed just as much the second time as the first.

Strongly Recommended!

Saints (Boxers & Saints #2) by Gene Luen Yang


Completed: February 5, 2014
Length: 170 Pages

Synopsis from Goodreads:
China, 1898. An unwanted and unwelcome fourth daughter, Four-Girl isn't even given a proper name by her family when she's born. She finds friendship--and a name, Vibiana--in the most unlikely of places: Christianity.
But China is a dangerous place for Christians. The Boxer Rebellion is in full swing, and bands of young men roam the countryside, murdering Westerners and Chinese Christians alike. Torn between her nation and her Christian friends, Vibiana will have to decide where her true loyalties lie...and whether she is willing to die for her faith.
I wish I had read this last year. I really liked this book! What Yang essentially does with this story is go back to the beginning with a character that will appear a couple times in Boxers. We see her difficult up-bringing and how she winds up turning to Christianity. Her grandfather would not give her a name; so she grew up being called Four-Girl until she is baptised and can rename herself to Vibiana. This is her story and I really liked the female-viewpoint. There is a female character that prominently appears in Boxers, but the story is only told from Bao's point of view. So, in just 170 pages Yang talks about gender issues, growing up a girl in China, Christianity, and the Boxer Rebellions. It is about half the size of Boxers but just as powerful.

I felt really bad for Vibiana. Her goal in life was just to get her grandfather to love and accept her, but nothing she tries works out. This leads her on an entirely different path away from her family and up-bringing. It gives her a chance to be herself and break away. It is not always perfect, though. She really struggles with her identity and her decisions. But, it is worth reading. I would definitely read Boxers first, though. And don't be like me, read them both at the same time! They really flow well together and like all of Yang's work, they are worth checking out. Not to forget, but this book also ties in Joan of Arc!

Strongly recommended!

(This post originally ran at The Written World.)

Friday, January 18, 2013

Sky Burial by Xinran

As a child, Xinran had heard stories of a soldier that had been fed to the vultures in what is known in Tibet as a Sky Burial. Several decades later, Xinran, by then a journalist and writer, met the wife of that soldier.

Sky Burial is the amazing story that was told to Xinran by the widow, known as Shu Wen.

It is the story of her love for her husband and the search for the truth surrounding his death. It is also the amazing story of realisation, friendship, bewilderment and the journey of China and Tibet during the 1950s.

For me, this was a breath taking read. It was selected by my local reading group and I devoured the book in one sitting. A fabulous book and definitely a favourite.

At the end of the book is an open letter from the author to Shu Wen, who left the area before Xinran had chance to talk to her again. Did Xinran ever make contact with Shu Wen? We have no way of knowing and I am itching to know!

Tuesday, August 7, 2012

Journeying To Journey Of The North Star by Douglas Penick


What I find so exciting and challenging in historical fiction is that it  enables me, as both writer and reader, to explore worlds that are real but which can only come to life on the edge of imagination. It's a kind of fiction that allows all of us to enter worlds we have lost. But in entering those worlds, we can experience kinds of intensities deep within us that may, right now, not find such clear expression in our contemporary world.
 
As the modern world becomes more tightly knit, we come to share a global economy, a globally distributed commercial culture, and increasingly similar ideas about life and living altogether.

The many different ways that people have explored in finding ways to live as a societies and cultures, the immense diversity of ways in which people have examined their existence on the planet and in the cosmos become buried beneath the uniformities of world culture. The past becomes a vast secret repository of innumerable ways of being alive. Of course, much of human experience has been horrific, brutal, unrelentingly cruel, hopeless; at the same time women and men have never ceased to create possibilities of splendor, safety, beauty, truth, love and transcendence. Entering the past through historical novels, we can examine our ordinary, daily experience of hope and fear, love and hate, triumph and loss, loneliness and community, chaos and order in a mirror that is both old and somehow completely new.


I became interested in Zhu Di, the Yong Le Emperor (1360-1424), when Trungpa Rinpoche, a Tibetan teacher who lived in the West, stated that he was an exemplar of a ruler who worked to bring about enlightened society. Study of Zhu Di's life revealed however a man alternately utterly ruthless and completely visionary. At that point, it was evident that to make such judgments based on western moral assumptions would not reveal very much. It was necessary to study the many aspects of Chinese history, philosophy and culture which gave birth to this man and created the context in which he saw himself. After 10 years, I had a superficial understanding that provided enough clues to go forward with the book. One thing was  completely clear: in the story of Zhu Di, it is China itself that is the main character.

China is the oldest continuous civilization on the planet. It is continuous in the sense that Chinese cultural and social life has retained the same spiritual and intellectual foundations for 5,000 years. Chinese civilization accepts that its existence in ever changing cyclical time is as decisive as its existence in space.

For more than four and a half millennia, Chinese rulers and thinkers have not doubted that to achieve genuine progress is actually to renew virtues that were perfected and written down in the distant past. In a similar way, Chinese people have considered reverence for and obedience to forbears and parents as the psychological and ethical core of personal behavior.

(This is, of course, shockingly different from our assumptions in the modern West where we often believe we must reject the work of those who came before and go beyond our parents to achieve a new and better world.)

The Chinese have also generally maintained a hierarchical view of humanity's place in the cosmos. Heaven rules over earth and it is humanity that joins the two. In the same way, the Emperor rules over humankind and is the balance point in maintaining both social and cosmic order. His relationship to his people is like that of a father to his children.

Zhu Di took control of China by rebelling against his nephew, but did so because he believed he alone could fulfill the vision of his father (the first Ming Emperor who was a peasant but seized the throne from the decadent Mongol emperors and wished to establish a genuinely Chinese dynasty). It was a brutal campaign with a bloody aftermath. Then as the Yong Le Emperor, he devoted himself to making China a great world power once again.  He re-structured the government, the judicial system, the military and the court, renewed the educational system, strengthened trade and diplomatic relations (and in the process built the largest fleet on the face of the earth and sent it out to as far as East Africa), rebuilt the Great Wall, built the Grand Canal, commissioned the greatest encyclopedia ever assembled, and moved the capital to Beijing which he had resigned and re-built, including its great center-piece, the Forbidden City.  As a skilled general, throughout his reign, he also rode with his armies on many expeditions against Mongol invaders. His direct mark on Chinese institutions remained for almost 500 years.


To tell the story of Yong Le's reign, to give some sense of him as a person and to provide the context in which he was making choices and decisions was at first overwhelming. I needed to find a lens through which I and the reader could see the whole thing in a manageable way. This stymied me for a long time. Then I was lucky enough to visit Beijing and luckier still to be able to spend several days exploring the Forbidden City.

This huge palace is in many ways the same as it was when the Yong Le Emperor built it.
On one of my visits, I was especially fortunate since there was a yellow windy fog, a kind of weather often mentioned in literature, caused by storms in the deserts to the north.  The Forbidden City is usually crowded with tourists from all over the world but especially from China. The weather that day left the palace more empty than usual. (The photos here may a give a sense of that day.)

I wandered in the mist through back alleys, peered through half-open wooden gates into the residences of minor consorts and eunuchs. There was a ghostly feeling to it all. I sensed that the Forbidden City was still haunted, not with the spirits of Emperors and Empresses and courtiers, but with the ghosts of the thousands of servants who had spent their lives there and still longed to return.


With that, I discovered the person who could tell the story: a court stenographer, the eunuch slave, Ma Yun. I heard his voice, and so I began the JOURNEY OF THE NORTH STAR like this:

" I have lived in the heart of the world. Amid many others of my kind, this eunuch slave has hurried silently, day and night, through the vermilion corridors of the Son of Heaven’s palaces to serve his needs as ruler of the world. Despite my utter insignificance, the Lord of Time has been so kind as to use this eunuch slave as one of his innumerable instruments in determining the way of life of unseen millions. "
                                                           *
Should you be interested, the book is available in e-book format at Amazon, Barnes&Noble, and many other sites. Thank you.

Douglas Penick                                                                        
MPDuke1@msn.com

Friday, July 27, 2012

Reading Chinese historical fiction

Today, I am thrilled to introduce James Lande from Old China Books to give us a fantastically comprehensive list of suggested reading about China!
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Historical Tapestry has invited me to guest post with a discussion of historical novels set in China. This in response to my comment (as Old China Books) on Mary Tod’s blog A Writer of History that I find historical fiction about China to be indifferently represented in forums devoted to the historical genre (HT, however, has a category for Chinese History with five entries).

I assume the principle reason for this scarcity may be that we American readers are not so familiar with Asian history; in our schools Western history generally receives more emphasis – Athens rather the Warring States, Rome instead of the Han Dynasty, the Hanover monarchs and not the Manchu empire. So, the Far East is a longer reach.

Still, the reasons for reading historical novels about China are not unlike those for reading historicals set in the West or near East. The people invoked have similar troubles and triumphs, and the events evoked have similar storm and stress – but in different contexts often fascinating in their contrast. We gain some insight into people of another time, and perhaps into how our time came to be, by sharing in their drama. Adventure, war, hard times, love, understanding – they live in the pages of historical fiction about China just as they do in that about other places.

And what am I calling historical fiction? In addition to novels about events regarded as historical, events older than 50 years according to some forums, there are included here titles that, while not historical when published, are set in places that time has since changed enough to make them quite different now and, as such, have become chronicles of the vanished past (e.g. Hong Kong of the 1950s).

There are original English-language novels about China, and Chinese-language novels widely available in translation. There are older books rarely heard of now (besides Pearl Buck), and more recent novels (besides Lisa See). And there are novels about Chinese-American experience (besides Amy Tan) I’ve left off the list because they are not quite historicals yet. Some of these are about earlier history and others are about more recent events. This list starts with comparatively modern novels about China.

Modern Novels about China

Pearl of China, Anchee Min, 2010. A fictional tale of a Chinese woman and her friendship with novelist Pearl S. Buck, beginning when they meet as children at the end of the nineteenth century. “In the southern town of Chin-kiang 鎮江, in the last days of the nineteenth century, two girls bump heads and become thick as thieves. Willow is the only child of a destitute local family. Pearl, the headstrong daughter of zealous Christian missionaries, will become Pearl S. Buck, Nobel Prize-winning writer and activist. Their friendship will be tested during decades of great tumult, by imprisonment and exile, bloody civil war and Mao’s repressive Communist regime [Anchee Min‘s website].” This book is a pleasant surprise for me, my first exposure to Anchee Min, and an extraordinary subject. See the Pearl of China book trailer on YouTube.

Peony in Love, Lisa See, 2007. In 17th century China, young Peony attends a performance of the opera Peony Pavilion on her 16th birthday and falls in love with a stranger. Already promised in marriage, she can only waste away with lovesickness for her beloved. Just before she dies, she learns that her betrothed and her beloved are the same man.
In any other story, that would be The End, but not in a Chinese story where the unfulfilled can return to the world as hungry ghosts and finish the cycle left incomplete by premature passing. “...spirits in the Chinese afterworld – whether beloved ancestors or ghosts – have the same wants, needs, and desires as living people. They need clothes, food, a place to live. They have emotions. [Peony] …can float, change form, and do many things that living people can’t do, but she is also inhibited – as all Chinese ghosts are – by things like corners, mirrors, and fern fronds [Lisa See website]." Ms See proceeds to create an entire other world where Peony finds her destiny. See Peony’s book trailer. Historical Tapestry also has a post on Peony.

Empress Orchid, Anchee Min, 2004. “…Within the walls of the Forbidden City the consequences of a misstep are deadly. As one of hundreds of women vying for the attention of the Emperor, Orchid soon discovers that she must take matters into her own hands. After training herself in the art of pleasing a man, she bribes her way into the royal bedchamber and seduces the monarch. A grand love affair ensues; the Emperor is a troubled man, but their love is passionate and genuine. Orchid has the great good fortune to bear him a son. Elevated to the rank of Empress, she still must struggle to maintain her position and the right to raise her own child. With the death of the Emperor comes a palace coup that ultimately thrusts Orchid into power, although only as regent until her son's maturity. Now she must rule China as its walls tumble around her, and she alone seems capable of holding the country together…[Amazon book description].”


The Last Empress, Anchee Min, 2008. “The last decades of the nineteenth century were a violent period in China’s history, marked by humiliating foreign incursions and domestic rebellions and ending in the demise of the Ch’ing Dynasty. The only constant during this tumultuous time was the power wielded by one woman, the resilient, ever-resourceful Tsu Hsi -- or Empress Orchid, as readers came to know her in Anchee Min’s critically acclaimed, best-selling novel covering her rise to power.

The Last Empress is the story of Orchid’s dramatic transition from a strong-willed, instinctive young woman to a wise and politically savvy leader who ruled China for more than four decades. In this concluding volume Min gives us a compelling, very human leader who assumed power reluctantly and sacrificed all to protect those she loved and an empire that was doomed to die [Amazon book description].”

Snow Flower and the Secret Fan, Lisa See, 2005. This is the story of a laotung 老同, a special bond between two women that creates intimacy even greater than that between husband and wife, and of the lifelong laotong between Lily and her friend Snow Flower. At the age of 80, Lily thinks back over the events of their lives they shared in letters written with secret writing called nu shu女書, through the reigns of four emperors, foot binding, betrothal, marriage, childbirth, war, poverty and death. They flee to the mountains to escape the Taiping rebels, and then return through killing fields piled with dead bodies. Misunderstanding leads to betrayal, in anger Lily shames her laotung, and only when Snow Flower lies dying is Lily able to come to Snow Flower’s bedside to ask for forgiveness. “Snow Flower and the Secret Fan is a story about friendship and what it means to be a woman [Lisa See, On Writing Snow Flower].” Historical Tapestry also has a post on Snow Flower.

The Rice Sprout Song, Eileen Chang, 1955. “The first of Eileen Chang's novels to be written in English, The Rice-Sprout Song portrays the horror and absurdity that the land-reform movement brings to a southern village in China during the early 1950s. Contrary to the hopes of the peasants in this story, the redistribution of land does not mean an end to hunger. Man-made and natural disasters bring about the threat of famine, while China's involvement in the Korean War further deepens the peasants' misery. Chang's chilling depiction of the peasants' desperate attempts to survive both the impending famine and government abuse makes for spellbinding reading. Her critique of communism rewrites the land-reform discourse at the same time it lays bare the volatile relations between politics and literature [Google Books].”

Spring Moon, Bette Bao Lord, 1981. Spring Moon begins in 1892, in the household of Chang, a wealthy Chinese family of Soochow. “At a time of mystery and cruelty...in an ancient land of breathtaking beauty and exotic surprise...a courageous woman triumphs over her world's ultimate tragedy. Behind the garden walls of the House of Chang, pampered daughter Spring Moon is born into luxury and privilege. But the tempests of change sweep her into a new world -- one of hardship, turmoil, and heartbreak, one that threatens to destroy her husband, her family, and her darkest secret love. Through a tumultuous lifetime, Spring Moon must cling to her honor, to the memory of a time gone by, and to a destiny, foretold at her birth, that has yet to be fulfilled [Amazon book description].”

The True Story of Ah Q, Lu Hsun (tr. Gladys Yang), 1921. “Considered a masterpiece, this story was written in 1921, and is set in the China of 1911: the period of the old democratic revolution. It concerns the tragedy of Ah Q, a farm laborer who suffers a lifetime of humiliation and persecution, dreams of revolution, and ends up on the execution ground. The story colorfully reflects the rural conditions in semi-feudal and semi-colonial China, and brings to life the time's sharp class contradictions and the peasant masses' demand for revolution. Its simplicity and directness of style, and the beauty of Lu Hsun's language, place The True Story of Ah Q high among literary works of the time for both content and style [Amazon book description].”

Family, Ba Jin (tr. Sidney Shapiro), 1933. The conflicts between young and old in Family mirrored the struggle in China following the May Fourth Movement of 1919. Five generations of the Kao family, upper-class Chinese living under one roof in 1920s Chengdu, are ruled over by autocratic elders who demand absolute obedience of the young brothers. The brothers yearn to break free of their narrow trappings and live lives of their own choosing, to marry as they wish, and to pursue opportunities in the New China. The elders see their family and the nation disintegrating together, youth throwing over the old customs that with the land made family the bedrock of their society, and fear what will happen when their children leave the village. Followed by Spring, and Autumn, in a trilogy called Torrents.

Rickshaw Boy (aka Rickshaw: The Novel Lo-t'o Hsiang Tzu 骆驼祥子, tr. Jean M. James; Camel Xiangzi), Lao She (tr. Evan King), 1937. “After Xiangzi’s parents die, he goes to the city of Beijing, bringing with him a country boy’s sturdiness and simplicity. He rents a rickshaw from Fourth Master Liu, who owns the Harmony Rickshaw-renting Yard, to make a living. Unlike the other rickshaw pullers, who are addicted to smoking, drinking, and visiting prostitutes, Xiangzi leads a decent, frugal life. His only dream is to have a rickshaw of his own. After three or four years of struggle and hardship, he saves enough money to buy a rickshaw, believing that the rickshaw will bring him freedom...[eNotes].”


China from a Western View


My Splendid Concubine, Lloyd Lofthouse, 2009. [Concubine Saga]
From a Far Land, Robert Elegant
Noble House, Clavell
Oil for the Lamps of China, Alice Tisdale Hobart, 1934

The Painted Veil, W. Somerset Maugham, 1925. A romantic period piece by an accomplished writer that tells of the marriage of an English bacteriologist Walter Fane on leave from China and a young and callow socialite Kitty who is completely at loose ends when taken to Hong Kong by her husband. Her affair with a local official revealed, Walter gives her a choice of leaving with him for a cholera district inland, or the scandal of divorce unless her lover will marry her. Heartbroken when her lover refuses her, Kitty accompanies her husband into China. “With beautiful China as a backdrop to this story of growth, The Painted Veil is a classic. It is beautifully written, the writing compact but amazingly detailed. Kitty is finely drawn and fully realized, Walter much more distant but still captivating [Katie Trattner, Blogcritics.com].”


A Single Pebble, John Hersey, 1956. An American engineer travels up the Yangtze River to Chungking in the 1920s. “In a deceptively simple story, Hersey has captured all the magic, the terror and the drama of that extraordinary stretch of water.... Even in Mr. Hersey's hands, the American's discoveries of his own mind and of the Chinese people are dwarfed by the laws, the demands and the ageless vitality of the Yangtze [The New York Times Book Review].”

The Mountain Road, Theodore H. White 1956. Journalist Teddy White's first novel tells of an American demolition unit behind lines in wartime China, charged with destroying bridges and ammunition dumps to delay advancing Japanese. In the midst of the American soldiers' struggle with their Chinese allies, and hoards of refugees crowding along mountain roads, the American major commanding falls in love with a Chinese woman and, through her, begins to learn profound things for which reading Pearl Buck had not prepared him.


A Many-Splendoured Thing, Han Suyin, 1952. “This is a book from a different age, when it was possible to develop a theme more slowly, but it remains a beautifully constructed many-layered novel. On the surface, it is a love story, but there is a fascinating historical perspective that is of particular interest as China's importance grows. Beneath those aspects is the insight into class and race prejudice that is as relevant today as it was in Hong Kong in the fifties. The book is strongly autobiographical yet remains a novel. Any reader would identify with or recognize characters from their own world [Amazon review by P. Inez Erica].”

The Warlord, Malcolm Bosse

World of Suzie Wong, Richard Mason, 1957. Englishman Robert Lomax moves into the Nam Kok Hotel in the Wanchai native quarter of 1950s Hong Kong to paint for a year. The first night, he discovers the hotel is a brothel that caters to foreign sailors, but he stays on anyway because of the picturesque location. As a houseguest, Lomax is treated like an elder brother and soon becomes acquainted with the girls and their problems, in particular Suzie Wong, and learns that most of the girls are ordinary people like anyone else, except for the work they do. Then Suzie decides Robert should be her regular boyfriend. “…a beautifully written book that provides an intimate portrait of post-WWII Hong Kong. For anyone who has lived in the former British colony, I guarantee you will be fascinated by Mason's astute observations of life in the territory [Amazon review by BJanis].”

 Man's Fate, Andre Malraux, 1933 (translated from the French La Condition Humaine), is a suspenseful story of the failure in 1927 of the Communist insurrection in Shanghai, the brutal retaliation of the Nationalists known now as the Shanghai Massacre, and the consequences for the characters involved. A tense dramatization of a watershed incident in the history of Modern China that many of us in the West only learned about and began to understand by reading this novel Man’s Fate.

The Sand Pebbles, Richard McKenna, 1962. An American gunboat, the San Pablo, on the upper reaches of the Yangtze River, is caught up in the anti-foreign violence fomented during the Nationalist march north, after the Shanghai Massacre, to purge the warlords and unify China. Woven into the story are romances between a San Pablo machinist and a young American missionary girl, and another San Pablo sailor and a Chinese woman ashore where the ship is stranded when the level of the river falls.

Taipan, James Clavell, 1966. A rousing tale of foreigners in South China at the time of the first Opium War in the early 1840s. Full of adventure and romance, the main characters are based on the British principals of Jardine Matheson, and Dent and Company, who manipulated England into war with the Chinese in order to protect their trade of opium for tea and silk, and to secure a foothold on the China coast where they could establish a trading entrepot.


Mandarin, Robert Elegant, 1983. A saga of extraordinary women of Shanghai Jewish families caught up in the events of the Taiping Rebellion and Second Opium War of 1860, Mandarin also follows the fortunes of the Last Empress, the dowager Ci-xi from her youth as concubine of the emperor to her palace intrigues and the coup that placed her on the imperial throne as regent. The sweep is broad, from 1854 to 1875, and all the principals of the era put in their cameos.


Our Hart, Elegy for a Concubine, Lloyd Lofthouse, 2010. [Concubine Saga] The subject of this novel is the British official Sir Robert Hart, known for his long service in China. The most balanced proponent of Lofthouse's treatment is, perhaps, one “Thomas Carter” who gives this in summary of Our Hart, Eulogy for a Concubine. “Robert Hart, as sketched by Lofthouse, was never, in fact, meant to be a hero. He is an admittedly flawed man with weaknesses.... But Hart's coming-of-age during his riotous first years in China, underscored by the tragic loss of one of his concubines, has now turned the boy into a man, and a bitter one at that, since ‘replacing the pain with anger made him feel like a thief and a liar.’ ...Just as our protagonist has matured, complete with a receding hairline, Our Hart… the novel is also a more mature read than its predecessor [see Carter's complete review].” See also the Historical Tapestry reviews of Lofthouse books.


Old Chinese Novels in Translation

Monkey, tr. Arthur Waley, 1942. The Chinese novel Journey to the West 西游记by Wu Ch’eng-en tells a picaresque tale of Sun Wu-k’ung, the mischievous Monkey King with magical powers, who is tasked by the Goddess of Mercy Kuan Yin to accompany a Buddhist priest and his friends on a legendary pilgrimage to India to bring back copies of the sacred scriptures. An adventure of the first water, the pilgrims are beset by all manner of fantastic challenges to their magical skills. Based on actual events of the early Tang Dynasty.

The Golden Lotus (aka The Plum in the Golden Vase), tr. David Tod Roy, 2006. Chin Ping Mei金瓶梅by Lanling Xiaoxiao Sheng蘭陵笑笑生 is an erotic novel set in the Sung Dynasty that relates the decline of the family of Hsi Men Ch’ing, a pawnshop owner and minor government official, due to his profligate ways. A procession of domestic and public life of the Sung period is depicted in detail – weddings, childbirth, funerals, birthdays, festivals, business deals, bribes to officials, brothel parties, songs and poetry. So is the procession of the great many women in Hsi-men Ch’ing’s life, lewd ladies who bring him to ruin. “…the greatest novel of physical love China has ever produced” – Pearl S. Buck.

The Water Margin (aka Outlaws of the Marsh, tr. Sidney Shapiro, 2002; All Men Are Brothers, tr. Pearl S. Buck, 1937). Shui Hu Chuan 水滸傳by Shih Nai-an. “…This 600 year-old epic tale of a band of patriots in the latter part of the Sung Dynasty is the story of a band of 108 outlaws (105 men and 3 women) who struggle to help the emperor rid himself of a despotic prime minister. Also involved in this work of classical Chinese fiction are ghosts, innkeepers who augment their groceries with the bodies of their guests, giants with superhuman strength, lovely ladies in distress, wily intellectuals, crafty merchants, and more! A sage replete with sorcery, action, beats, demons and heroes. All Men Are Brothers is a terrific read from beginning to end…. [Moyer Bell at The Free Library]….”

The Romance of the Three Kingdoms, tr. Moss Roberts, 2000. San Guo Yen Yi 三國演義, Luo Kuan-chung, Ming Dynasty. An epic historical novel with many episodes and characters that enjoys a stature in the East like that of Shakespeare in the West, Three Kingdoms tells of the struggle of three heroes to support the Han Dynasty emperor against rebels and warlords. Beginning with their oath of brotherhood in the Peach Garden, the three set forth to help put down the Yellow Turbans, then defend the throne against the ambitious prime minister Cao Cao. As events progress, first one of the sworn brothers falls, then another, leaving the third to pursue vengeance for their deaths. Ultimately, the kingdoms fall, the dynasty disintegrates, and the first sentence of the novel is borne out: The novels begins 话说天下大势,分久必合,合久必分It is said that in this world what is long divided will unite, and that what is united most certainly will break apart.

The Dream of the red Chamber (Hung Lou Meng 紅樓夢), tr. Chi Chen Wang (abridged), 1927, 1958; aka The Story of the Stone, tr. David Hawkes, John Mitford, 1982-2006. Hung Lou Meng, widely regarded as a book for the mellenia, is an episodic tale of two branches of the wealthy and influential Chia clan, who live in adjacent compounds in the capital and have enjoyed imperial favor for generations. The narrative centers on the dissolute youth Pao-yu and the captivating women of the household. The jealousies between them bring grief to the family and eventual downfall. “The novel is remarkable not only for its huge cast of characters and psychological scope, but also for its precise and detailed observation of the life and social structures typical of 18th-century Chinese aristocracy [Wikipedia].”

 

The Chinese-American Experience


The Woman Warrior, Maxine Hong Kingston, 1975. Maxine Hong Kingston looks at Chinese history from the perspective of a Chinese girl growing up in America among ghosts of the past. It may be thin to regard this chimera as historical fiction, but the book begins in 1924 and, together with the vital spirit of Hua Mu-lan – the woman warrior who took her father's place in battle – gives the book its toehold on the genre. Maxine's mother told her the story of Mu-lan, in Chinese talk-story style, to encourage her daughter to grow up into a woman warrior, with courage and initiative, rather than as wife and a slave. Many other voices contribute to this talk-story, placing the anomalies of modern American life encountered by many of Chinese descent who grow up in America into the context of the old ways.

1000 Pieces of Gold, Ruthanne Lum McCunn, 1981. A true story of triumph over extraordinary hardship suffered by a young girl sold into sexual slavery in 19th century China, to a gang of Chinese bandits, then into a brothel. Transported into the American wild west by a slave merchant, she is auctioned to a saloonkeeper, and antied up in a poker game won by Charley Bemis. The irony of the title is bitter - 1000 pieces of gold, ch'ien-chin hsiao-chieh 千金小姐, was originally a Chinese endearment for the unmarried daughters of the rich that came to mean any unmarried girl, who in practice were maimed, sold into marriage, concubinage, or slavery, or drowned. “Granted, the writing is simple and spare, but it does not purport to be a work of great literature. Instead, it is a simple re-telling (if fictionalized) of a brave Chinese/Mongolian woman, a stranger in a strange land [comment by wild-one on Amazon review].”

 Transcendent Western Writers about China

House of Earth, Pearl S. Buck. House of Earth is the title of Buck’s trilogy of life in rural China: The Good Earth, Sons, and A House Divided. Her style is simple and straightforward, almost biblical in places, which works well enough for stories set on farms and in the countryside, and her characters are individuals and the China around them is viewed through their eyes. Buck's portrayal of Chinese, and especially Chinese women, was regarded as a significant departure from the way they were depicted by American writers up to that time. This is less surprising considering that she grew up in China, spoke the language and, when she returned to China after graduating from college, and married agricultural expert John Lossing Buck, she spent the next five years traipsing about the countryside meeting Chinese farm families. She won the Pulitzer in 1932, and the Nobel for Literature in 1938.

The Good Earth, 1931. “It was Wang Lung’s marriage day.” Thus begins a classic novel of China revered for generations that tells of an honest farmer Wang Lung and his patient wife Olan and their life on the land. They raise sons and daughters, but drought and famine force them to sell everything except the land and their house and move to the city. Wang Lung pulls a rickshaw while Olan and the children beg in the streets. Riots break out and a mob sweeps Wang Lung into a rich man's house where he robs the owner of all his money. Wang Lung takes his family back home and they resume farming and even hire hands to work the land. Wang Lung prospers, sends his sons to school, and buys a concubine. Still, there is no peace for the old man, when Olan dies and his sons argue about selling the land.


Sons, 1932. The Wang Lung family saga continues after his death with the fate of his three sons, Wang the Landlord, Wang the Merchant, and Wang the Tiger, who has returned a soldier in a warlord army. Rather than pass on the land to the eldest son and keep it together, the land is divided between the three sons, which begins the dissipation of their inheritance. After selling his portion, Wang the Tiger goes off to war, builds his own army, and fights against other warlords for local control. As his own son Wang Yuan grows, Wang the Tiger prepares him to take command of the warlord army despite the son’s preference for farming the land. The son goes off for military training, but returns a soldier of a revolutionary army determined to wipe out all the warlords.

A House Divided, 1935. Wang Yuan, son of Wang the Tiger, returns to his grandfather’s old house of earth, t’u-fang 土房 , however the local farmers are afraid to allow him hide there. He returns home, then flees to his sister on the coast to avoid an arranged marriage. Wang Yuan settles down and starts classes in agriculture, which ironically take him out into the fields to learn from farmers what his grandfather could of taught him – and comes full circle. Revolution interferes, however, and Wang Yuan is arrested, his family pays to get him released, and he leaves for America. He continues his studies, flirts with romance, and six years later returns to a China still embroiled civil war. Through the many difficulties that follow, Wang Yuan’s longing to return to the old house of earth never wanes.

Imperial Woman, Pearl S. Buck, 1956. “The Empress Dowager…is the central figure of this enthralling biographical novel…. China, knew her as a figure of awe, virtually a goddess, and [Buck] has here told the story-book tale of her life, from concubine to one of the world’s most powerful and terrifying figures. …Tzu Hsi, concubine of the third rank, ambitious, beautiful, intelligent far beyond her time. She loved one man only, Jung Lu, a cousin to whom she was plighted at the time she was chosen for the weakling emperor. But once within the palace, the lust for power became her controlling guide, and nothing was allowed to divert her. Pearl Buck has embroidered her story with glamorous details of the aspects of the life of the fabulous court. She has drawn a wholly credible picture of the rivalries, and the plots that constantly threatened the Dragon Throne. …she never loses sight of Tzu Hsi in all her moods, in her brilliance and cruelty and ruthlessness, in her growing hate for the foreigners…[Kirkus Reviews].”

Some other titles by Pearl S. Buck

Peony
Kinfolk
The Mother
Dragon Seed
Pavilion of Women
East Wing, West Wind
The Three Daughters of Madame Liangs

The Judge Dee mysteries, Robert van Gulik. These novels are a subcategory of historical fiction – “historical whodunits.” Van Gulik was a Dutch orientalist and diplomat who, during WWII, served with the Dutch mission to the Nationalist government in Chungking, where he began translating the 18th-century Chinese novel Dee Goong An狄公案, about a T'ang Dynasty detective Ti Ren-chieh. Van Gulik married a Chinese of the imperial line, had four children, and after the war lived four years in Japan, where he started writing tales about Judge Dee. The fictional Judge Dee was based on the historical figure Ti Ren-chieh of the novel Dee Gong An, and van Gulik developed a mystery formula in which the judge solved several cases in one novel and generally avoided supernatural features common in novels of the period that the author thought might confuse Western readers. The judge’s clerk Sergeant Hoong originally assisted the judge in Holmes-Watson fashion, but as the novels progressed, the judge converted various criminals who became his followers and brought their nefarious skills to bear on solving cases.

The Celebrated Cases of Judge Dee, 1948. There are three cases in this book. The first might be called The Double Murder at Dawn. The case describes the hazardous life of the traveling silk merchant and the murder, which is committed to gain wealth. The second is The Strange Corpse, which takes place in a small village, a crime of passion, which proves hard to solve. The criminal is a very determined woman. The third case The Poisoned Bride contains the murder of the daughter of a local scholar who marries the son of the former administrator of the district. This case contains a surprising twist in its solution. All three cases are solved by Judge Dee, the district magistrate - detective, prosecutor, judge, and jury all wrapped up into one person [Wikipedia].

The Chinese Bell Murders, 1958. Judge Dee is a newly appointed magistrate to the town of Poo-yang. He has one case left over from the previous judge, a brutal rape-murder of a woman called Pure Jade. She was the daughter of a local butcher named Hsai who lived on Half Moon Street. The girl's lover stands accused but Judge Dee senses something in the case is not right, so he sets out, with his aids, to find the real murderer. He also has to wrestle with the problem of Buddhist Temple of Boundless Mercy, run by the abbot called "Spiritual Virtue." Rumor has it that the monks, who can cure barren women, are not as virtuous as they seem [Wikipedia].

Some other titles by Robert van Gulik

The Chinese Lake Murders
The Chinese Nail Murders
The Haunted Monastery
The Chinese Gold Murders
The Red Pavilion
Poets and Murder
Murder in Canton
Judge Dee at Work
The Willow Pattern
The Lacquer Screen
The Emperor’s pearl
Necklace and Calabash
The Monkey and the Tiger
The Chinese Maze Murders
The Phantom of the Temple

About the author of this post, James Lande

Marg suggested I post in the “Why do I love…” section. So, why do I love historical fiction about China? Well, first of all, because that’s what I write and publish – let’s get that out of the way now. Sometime in the long lost past I decided “okay, let’s write about China,” and my first real effort was in 1970 when, at the age of 25, I returned to China to write The Cinnabar Phoenix (stop googling – it was never finished). I had a decent command of Chinese and some time on station in China, and still accepted with little qualification the imperative of my high school English teacher Mrs Jane Roy that I should be a writer. Since then I’ve been hacking away at it, for longer than I should have to admit, and have never got the Monkey off my back (Monkey is the title of a classic Chinese novel). Ultimately, my own experience led me to choose writing about the encounter, sometimes the clash, between Americans and Chinese.

Along the way, I have read quite a few novels about China and, as I believe them to be underrepresented in American forums of historical fiction, I’ve wriggled into Historical Tapestry on the pretext that I can introduce some interesting titles to this readership.

My own novel about China I call Yankee Mandarin and I blog at the Writer’s Corner of the Old China Books book blog.

Monday, June 25, 2012

Why I love Sir Robert Hart's Lust for a Concubine in 19th Century China by Lloyd Lofthouse

There is an old, well known axiom — which came first, the chicken or the egg? For man, that question should be — which comes first, lust or love?

The answer for Robert Hart was lust while he was attending the Queen's College, Belfast (1950 - 1953), and the love came later in China after 1955.
As a young man, Hart's Wesleyan Methodist conscience failed to prevent bouts of promiscuity. While attending the Queen's College in Belfast, he seduced too many women and his reward was a dose of syphilis, which was probably treated and cured with the primary treatment, which was mercury in the form of calomel, ointments, steam baths, pills, and other concoctions. Another medicine to treat syphilis was Guajacum—used to treat the STD since the 16th century.

About a year after arriving in China, Robert met and bought Ayaou, a Chinese concubine, with whom he developed genuine affection and respect.
In fact, after his decade-long romance with Ayaou, there was no evidence that he sought a lusty romance with anyone else. In "Entering China's Service, Robert Hart's Journals, 1854—1863" the editors wrote, "Hart's years of liaison with Ayaou gave him his fill of romance, including both its satisfaction and its limitations."

One can only imagine what Hart experienced during his romance with Ayaou that nothing else ever equaled or surpassed it.

Of course, if it hadn't been for Sir Robert Hart burning his journals covering the first 2 years and nine months of that romance, my curiosity may not have been aroused enough to discover more about this lusty relationship, which led to more than a decade studying China's history and culture.

Sterling Seagrave wrote in "Dragon Lady" that "he (Hart) had a sleep-in dictionary, his concubine, Ayaou. He had just turned twenty; Ayaou was barely past puberty but was wise beyond her years. Thanks to her his life settled into a quiet routine and he was able to get on with his… Chinese studies, quickly becoming fluent in Mandarin and Ningpo Dialect."

Seagrave said, "Robert was raised a strict Wesleyan… Life was all work and pleasure was sinful."

It was those lusty pleasures that Hart experienced with Ayaou for a decade in the middle of the 19th century that caused him to burn those journals a half century later in an attempt to erase his sinful love of Ayaou from the record, but he failed and although we do not know much about Ayaou, we do know that she was real and had a significant impact on his life.

Through Ayaou, Hart learned to love China and had great plans for its future. He wrote, "I want to make China strong, and I want to make England her best friend."

Hart's skills as Inspector-General of Chinese Maritime Customs were recognized by both Chinese and Western leaders, and he earned several Chinese honorific titles, including the Red Button, or button of the highest rank, a Peacock's Feather, the Order of the Double Dragon, the Ancestral Rank of the First Class of the First Order for Three Generations, and the title of Junior Guardian of the Heir Apparent. He also received a baronetcy from Britain's Queen Victoria, and in 1906 he was awarded a Grand Cross of the Order of the Danneborg by the King of Denmark.

In "The Concubine Saga", my goal was to breathe life back into that bitter-sweet romance that existed between Robert Hart and his concubine Ayaou.
***********
Lloyd Lofthouse is the author of My Splendid Concubine and Our Hart [combined in this single volume], which earned honorable mentions in general fiction at the 2008 London Book Festival, 2009 San Francisco Book Festival, 2009 Hollywood Book Festival, 2009 Los Angeles Book Festival, 2009 Nashville Book Festival and was a finalist in historical fiction for the National Best Books 2010 Awards. Lloyd Lofthouse grew up in Southern California, served in the Vietnam War as a U.S. Marine and lives near San Francisco with his wife and family with a second home in Shanghai, China.

Leave an approved comment on one or more Blog posts found at Lloyd Lofthouse.org or iLook China.net
between May 30, 2012 and June 30, 2012
during "The Concubine Saga" Web Tour
and automatically be entered into a drawing
to win a limited edition, signed and numbered hard-cover copy of the novel.
(NOTE: only one limited-edition, hard-cover copy is available to give away)

Sunday, February 5, 2012

All the Flowers in Shanghai by Duncan Jepson

In 1930's Shanghai, following the path of duty takes precedence over personal desires for every young Chinese woman. For Feng, that means becoming the bride of a wealthy businessman in a marriage arranged by her parents. In the enclosed world of the Sang household  - a place of public ceremony and private cruelty - she learns that fulfilling her duty means bearing a male heir. Ruthless and embittered by a life that has been forced on her, Feng plots a terrible revenge. But as the years pass, she must come to a reckoning with the sacrifices and the terrible choices she has made to assure her place in family and society, before the entire country is engulfed in the fast-flowing tide of revolution.
Some times you read a book that makes you grateful that you live in this time and this place. Sure, in 50 years time our grandkids might look back and wonder how we put up with .... whatever, but for the most part here in Australia we have a pretty free and easy lifestyle. I do know though that some times that is not always the case. For example, when I was pregnant and having my ultrasound scans, there were signs everywhere which advised us not to ask to find out the sex of the child as we wouldn't be told. When asked why I was advised that it was to prevent people who didn't want a girl to do anything untoward. That was only 14 or so years ago. And, of course, there are millions of women around the world who have little or no freedom to make choices regarding their own lives.

This book is set in the late 1930s in Shanghai, where life was lived by very strict rules and traditions, especially for girls. Feng is a young, very naive girl who has grown up in the shadow of her elder sister, who in the novel goes only by the name Sister. Sister has been trained from a young age to be all that is desirable in the eyes of the richer families in Shanghai. She knows how to dress, how to perform ancient traditions like the tea ceremonies, how to catch a rich and influential husband for one reason and one reason only - to raise her family up the social ladder.

Feng on the other hand has been left to grow up under the much more relaxed rules of her grandfather; spending time in the gardens, learning the names of flowers etc. It is not expected that she will marry but rather that she will look after her parents when the time comes.

One of the most important things for a socially ambitious family is to never lose face or cause offense to those who are better than them. Therefore, when Sister is unable to fill her obligation to marry, Feng is forced to do so instead despite the fact that she has had barely any training and that she is very, very naive.

She marries into the wealthy Sang family, where traditions are expected to be maintained diligently and her sole reason for existence is to provide an heir. Her husband is initially understanding of her shyness when it comes to intimate matters but things change once the pressure builds from his family.

I found the initial parts of the book to be quite interesting. The author spent a lot of time drawing a picture of what it was like to be a young Chinese woman in those time with no choices over their future and by looking at both Feng and Sister we get to see the two different sides of that. We get details of the lavish efforts that went into attracting the right kind of suitors for a socially ambitious family include the beautiful wedding dress that must be made. For Feng there is also a nice friendship with Bi, the son of the seamstress.

It is after the marriage, and when Feng moves into the Sang home that the narrative started to falter. Part of that reflects the restrictions that were placed on Feng. She was barely allowed out of the home and so we no longer get to see anything of Shanghai through her eyes. In addition, Feng quickly transitions from an innocent young girl to a very bitter woman, from a naive young girl to a woman who knows how to titillate and humiliate her husband, who as a character is very one dimensional throughout the novel. In fact, most of the characters outside of Feng seem somewhat limited. Perhaps this is as a result of the fact that we only get to see these people from her view point, but perhaps there was not enough page time given to them to develop.

It was also difficult to empathise with Feng when she makes a decision in the middle of the book (to say anymore would be spoiling). Yes, we knew why she had made the decision that she had made, but it was not one that I could have made, and her initial actions and reactions were quite hard to believe. It was a relief when the book progressed a bit further and it was at last clear through her thoughts that she was haunted by the decisions that she had made. There were some plot holes in relation to this, particularly in terms of when the husband finds out what she has done, but before she can find out his reaction she fled so as not to have to face the consequences of her actions.

I came to this book as a reader of historical fiction, so I was a bit disappointed to see that after the initial set up, the historical details seemed to fade into black, especially given that there were pretty significant events taking place at the time. For example, the Japanese invasion of China was glossed over in just a couple of sentences and the lead up to the Cultural Revolution was pretty brief. By the end of the novel though, I was glad to see that Jepson did spend some time talking about the Cultural Revolution and the effect that those events had on Feng's life even if the mechanism to get her to that point was a little clunky. Feng looks back on her former life and it is clear that she comes to the realisation of how bitter and terrible she was to the people around her, which is very lucky because otherwise she would have been a completed unlikable narrator.

Whilst this book didn't completely work for me, there were glimpses of promise that included an interesting setting. If you are looking for historical fiction with a Chinese setting I would probably recommend Lisa See, or The Good Earth books by Pearl Buck before this one.

Originally post at The Adventures of An Intrepid Reader

Thursday, July 16, 2009

The Painter from Shanghai by Jennifer Cody Epstein


Stirring Portrait of an Artist

Pan Yuliang never envisioned that her life would turn out like this. When her mother died, she was sent to her uncle's house. He raised her along with the help of a maid. She was to be promised to a man and then be married. That is what her mother's wish for her and a promise from her uncle.However, her uncle had a drug habit and ran out of money. He had to get drugs somehow, so he sold Yuliang into prostitution at the age of 14.

She was brought to "The Hall of Eternal Splendor" and was taught the ways of seduction and "bed business."

She was told to seduce the new inspector, Pan Zanhua. This was very important so that he could be kept in line and continue turning a blind eye, as the old inspector did. However, it did not work out that way. He could not be bought. He didn't fall for the hook as much as he was attracted to Yuliang.

Yuliang knew her fate. "Grandmother," the madam would beat her unmercifully. Pan Zanhua saw she was crying and he got her to tell him the truth. Zanhua rescued her from her fate and took her in as his concubine.

Zanhua really believed in equality and gave Yuliang an education. She became fascinated with art and started sketching. As her career as an artist took off both her and Zanhua become torn between her success and their love for each other.

Pan Yuliang was a real person, a famous artist. This book of historical fiction fills in what parts of her life may have been like. Jennifer cody Epstein really did her research and paints a colourful portrait of the life of Pan Yaliang. I felt like I was there as a witness to everything she endured and her triumph as an artist. The characters are believable and the writing is beautiful and richly textured.

This books is a real page turner and kept me up into the wee hours of the morning. I just couldn't put it down! I cannot recommend this book high enough. It does not disappoint!

5/5




Baby Arms by Pan Yuliang

Saturday, September 22, 2007

Peony in Love by Lisa See

“I finally understand what the poets have written. In spring, moved to passion; in autumn only regret.”

For young Peony, betrothed to a suitor she has never met, these lyrics from The Peony Pavilion mirror her own longings. In the garden of the Chen Family Villa, amid the scent of ginger, green tea, and jasmine, a small theatrical troupe is performing scenes from this epic opera, a live spectacle few females have ever seen. Like the heroine in the drama, Peony is the cloistered daughter of a wealthy family, trapped like a good-luck cricket in a bamboo-and-lacquer cage. Though raised to be obedient, Peony has dreams of her own.

Peony’s mother is against her daughter’s attending the production:
“Unmarried girls should not be seen in public.” But Peony’s father assures his wife that proprieties will be maintained, and that the women will watch the opera from behind a screen. Yet through its cracks, Peony catches sight of an elegant, handsome man with hair as black as a cave–and is immediately overcome with emotion.

So begins Peony’s unforgettable journey of love and destiny, desire and sorrow–as Lisa See’s haunting new novel, based on actual historical events, takes readers back to seventeenth-century China, after the Manchus seize power and the Ming dynasty is crushed.

Steeped in traditions and ritual, this story brings to life another time and place–even the intricate realm of the afterworld, with its protocols, pathways, and stages of existence, a vividly imagined place where one’s soul is divided into three, ancestors offer guidance, misdeeds are punished, and hungry ghosts wander the earth. Immersed in the richness and magic of the Chinese vision of the afterlife, transcending even death, Peony in Love explores, beautifully, the many manifestations of love. Ultimately, Lisa See’s new novel addresses universal themes: the bonds of friendship, the power of words, and the age-old desire of women to be heard.



I am going to have to be honest, when I started this book I was not sure if I was going to like it. I even put it down for a few days, but I picked it back up today and did not put it back down again (willingly) until I finished it. In many ways it is hard to compare this book to Lisa See's Snow Flower and the Secret Fan. They take place in different time periods, but at the core they are stories of women facing adverse circumstances in society. A common theme in both books is writing, and expressing themselves in words. In Snow Flower and the Secret Fan, the girls express themselves through the writings on a fan. Peony in Love is predominately about a piece of writing and how it inspires women to write.

The aspect of the book that I was not sure about at first is that the main character of the novel dies and then continues to narrate the story as a ghost. I was not sure if that was not going to get a bit corny, but Lisa See carried it off very well. She has written a very lyrical novel that easily expresses the connection that the Chinese had with the afterworld. This novel is very much about love, like the title tells us, but that is not all that is happening here. In China at this time, many women were never taught to write. People did not like the fact that Peony could write because it was not a 'womanly' thing to do. Some men were revolutionary, though, and believed that their wives should able to be educated.

The authors note at the end of the book explains how this is historical fiction and how Lisa See came up with the idea. The story is based on a real opera, The Peony Pavilion which was written by Tang Xianzu and set during the Song dynasty, but apparently that was not the period he was talking about. To learn more about the history of the opera and how it became important to See, you will have to read the book and author's note.

I think I liked this book because it touched on issues that are even still present in society. It is a novel about women rising up against the men in society and doing something for themselves. I think I could almost call it inspiring. And, I liked the afterworld idea after a while. I think it was interesting that the ancestors of those still living became characters in the book. You could even overlook the way that Peony died by the end because Lisa See made it look right. I think this book will touch the romantic in people. I am very happy that I read it. Many others like her other book better, but I think this just became my favourite.